Ben Waber hat Aristocracy, American Style von Nancy Isenberg besprochen
An Intriguing but Confused History
3 Sterne
This is an intriguing but imprecise history, with Isenberg arguing that in the absence of a hereditary aristocracy based on noble titles the US has reconstituted that system based on other social markers. I largely think this is true, but unfortunately this book provides only weak, mostly qualitative evidence to support that claim. Most importantly, Isenberg regularly conflates fame and success with aristocracy, rather than demonstrating that certain kinds of status are inherited. She takes an individual, case-focused view of this issue, which beyond being unconvincing also glaringly includes people who demonstrably did not inherit or pass on their status. It also includes a strange focus on some political figures' use of nice modes of transportation, which is arguably important in establishing the legitimacy of a state. There are some interesting cases in here, though